← Back to blog

How to choose an AEO agency: what to look for and what to ask

Every SEO agency now sells AEO or GEO. Some have changed how they work. Many have changed only the name of the package. The difference shows up in what they measure and what they can show you, so this guide gives you a short process and a list of questions that expose it quickly.

For the full buyer checklist with scoring, see our page on how to choose an AEO agency. This post is the shorter version you can take into a sales call.

How to choose the best AEO agency?

Pick the agency that can prove it moves AI answers: it tracks named mentions and citations across ChatGPT, Perplexity and Google AI Overviews, reports at the level of individual prompts, and has a clear plan for earning third-party mentions. Price and team size come after those three.

Step 1: Write down the prompts you want to win

Before you talk to anyone, list 15 to 20 questions your buyers ask an AI assistant on the way to choosing a product like yours. Mix category questions, comparisons and problem questions. This list becomes your test: every agency should talk about these prompts, not about generic traffic.

Step 2: Check the three non-negotiables

  • They measure AI citations. Ask to see a live report. It should show which brands each engine names and which sources it cites, for prompts like yours.
  • They report prompt by prompt. A single "AI visibility score" hides what changed. You want to see prompt X, engine Y, before and after.
  • They earn third-party mentions. AI answers lean on review sites, forums, directories and press. An agency that only edits your own site will hit a ceiling. Ask how they handle AI citation outreach.

Step 3: Ask the 12 questions below

Use the checklist in the next section on every call, and score each answer from 0 to 2. Agencies that cannot answer a question with an example score zero on it.

Step 4: Ask for a paid audit before a retainer

A good agency will happily start with a fixed-scope audit. It sets your baseline and shows you how they work. If they push straight to a 12-month retainer, treat that as a warning. Our post what is an AEO audit explains what the audit should include.

Step 5: Compare proposals on the same terms

Put every proposal into one table: engines tracked, number of prompts, reporting frequency, content volume, off-site work, technical work, team and price. Proposals that look cheaper often track fewer prompts or skip off-site work entirely. Once the scope matches, the price gap usually narrows, and the real difference is in method and proof.

Step 6: Check references and the team

Ask to speak to one current client in a market like yours, and ask who will run your account day to day. Senior people on the sales call and juniors on the work is a common pattern. Meet the person who will own your prompt set before you sign.

A worked example

Say you run marketing at a B2B payroll SaaS selling in the US. Your prompt list includes "best payroll software for startups", "alternatives to [your main competitor]" and "how to run payroll for remote contractors". You speak to three agencies. Agency A shows rankings and traffic and says AI visibility will follow. Agency B shows an AI visibility score but cannot break it down by prompt. Agency C runs two of your prompts live on the call, shows which review sites ChatGPT cites for them, and proposes an audit first. Agency C is the only one that passes all three non-negotiables. [PROOF NEEDED: replace with an anonymised real example from our sales calls, with permission]

What to look for in an SEO company?

Look for an SEO company that ties its work to buyer questions and revenue, shows dated proof from real clients, explains its method in plain language, and is clear about what it will not promise. For AI search, add one test: can they show you how AI assistants answer your buyers today?

The 12-question checklist for the sales call

  1. Which AI engines do you track, and how often do you re-run the prompts?
  2. Can you show me a live report for a current client, with the brand hidden?
  3. How do you build the prompt set, and will I approve it?
  4. Do you report share of answers per prompt and per competitor?
  5. How do you log which sources each engine cites?
  6. What do you do about third-party sources such as review sites, Reddit and directories?
  7. How do you check that AI assistants describe our product accurately?
  8. Which technical checks do you run for AI crawlers, schema and llms.txt?
  9. Who writes the content, and who checks facts and claims before it goes live?
  10. What results have you got for a company like ours, and can I speak to that client?
  11. What will you deliver in the first 30, 60 and 90 days?
  12. What does it cost, what is included, and what would make the price change?

[COPY NEEDED: link to the downloadable checklist PDF once it exists]

Red flags

  • Guaranteed placements. No one controls what ChatGPT says. An agency that guarantees you will be "the top answer" is selling something it cannot deliver.
  • Screenshots without dates or prompts. AI answers change. Undated screenshots prove nothing.
  • One blended score. If you cannot see the prompts behind a number, you cannot check it.
  • No plan for off-site sources. If the whole plan is blog posts on your own domain, expect slow results.
  • Mass AI content. Publishing hundreds of thin AI-written pages tends to hurt trust with both search engines and AI assistants.
  • No named team. You should know who does the work and their experience. See our own AEO team for the standard we hold ourselves to.

What are some common questions asked about SEO?

The questions buyers ask most are how long SEO takes, what it costs, what results to expect, and whether they need an agency at all. With AI search, add two more: will SEO still matter, and how do I show up in ChatGPT answers. Here are short answers you can use to test an agency.

  • How long does it take? Technical fixes can be picked up within weeks of a recrawl. Content and third-party mentions take longer. Be wary of anyone who gives a firm date for AI placements.
  • What does it cost? It depends on scope, market and how competitive your category is. See our AEO pricing and our comparison of AEO cost in India vs the US.
  • Do I need an agency? Not always. A strong in-house team with the right tools can do much of the work. Our page on AEO agency vs in-house helps you decide.
  • Is SEO still worth it? Yes. AI answers still pull heavily from pages that rank and get cited, so SEO and AEO work best together. We cover this in is SEO dead or turning into AEO/GEO.

When is it worth getting help?

Get help when you know AI search matters to your buyers but you lack the time or tools to measure it, or when a competitor keeps appearing in AI answers and you cannot see why. Start small, with an audit, so you can judge the agency on real work.

Use the full checklist on our how to choose an AEO agency page, then put us through the same test. Book an AI Visibility Audit and we will show you, prompt by prompt, where you stand today.

Need GTM creative shipped at AI speed?

One team for content, decks, landing pages, SEO/GEO, and video.

Get started